What Is Meihua Yishu? How It Differs from Liu Yao

Meihua Yishu is famous among Chinese divination students because it feels fast, flexible, and mysterious. It reads through images and numbers, often beginning from a sudden trigger: a time, number, sound, object, or scene. That makes it quite different from Liu Yao, which relies on a more technical rule system.

A boundary first: this article covers the traditional casting rules, body-use judgment, and the structural difference from Liu Yao. It is not a comparison of predictive power. Hexagrams should not be treated as a tool for judging real events, health, finances, or relationship outcomes. Having a classical text does not make a reading valid.

What Is Meihua Yishu?

Meihua Yishu is a Yijing-based divination method that casts with pre-heaven trigram numbers and judges through body-use generation and control plus symbolic reading. It is traditionally attributed to Shao Yong (Shao Kangjie) of the Northern Song, but the surviving text carries a Qing-dynasty preface by Huang Zongxi, and its plum-blossom origin story is described as later transmission. Authorship and date of compilation remain disputed, so it should not be treated as Shao Yong's autograph. [1]

Setting authorship aside, its main traits as a method are fairly clear:

  • Flexible casting: time, numbers, sounds, directions, and visible objects can all serve as the starting data.
  • Pre-heaven trigram numbers: Qian 1, Dui 2, Li 3, Zhen 4, Xun 5, Kan 6, Gen 7, Kun 8.
  • Body and use trigrams: the body trigram is the main side and the use trigram is the matter; the common rule is that the trigram containing the moving line is use, and the other is body.
  • Image and five-phase relations: judgment starts from the body-use relation, then adds mutual and changed hexagrams plus symbolic reading.

How Does Meihua Yishu Cast a Hexagram?

In the transmitted year-month-day-hour method, the key point is that "year" means the ordinal of the year branch, not the Western calendar year:

  1. Upper trigram: add the year-branch number (Zi year 1, Chou 2, through Hai 12), the lunar month number, and the lunar day number. Divide by 8 and use the remainder with the pre-heaven numbers. A remainder of 0 means 8, Kun.
  2. Lower trigram: add the hour-branch number (Zi hour 1 through Hai 12) to that total, divide by 8, and use the remainder; 0 again means Kun.
  3. Moving line: divide the total of year, month, day, and hour by 6. A remainder of 0 means the sixth line, the top line, not line zero.
  4. Body and use: by the transmitted rule, the trigram without the moving line is body and the trigram with it is use; body is the subject and use is the matter.

Beyond time, the text also lists casting by the number of objects, sounds, written characters, and measurements; modern teaching may add direction, colour, or a scene in front of you. The method can be flexible, but the numbers still have to be taken in a consistent order rather than skipped for a feeling. [1]

Body and Use: The Core Judgment

Once the hexagram is formed, the basic dimension is the five-phase relation between body and use. The text says the body is the subject and the use is the matter, and reads fortune directly from that relation:

RelationMeaningBasic reading in the text
Use generates bodyThe outer side supports the subjectFavorable; matters tend to go smoothly
Body generates useThe subject gives energy outwardModerately favorable; effort is required
Body controls useThe subject can manage the situationPowerful; the matter can be handled
Use controls bodyExternal forces restrict the subjectUnfavorable; obstacles need caution
Body and use share a phaseBoth belong to the same elementRead as favorable in the text, subject to strength and images

"Sharing a phase" is not a neutral balance of equal forces; it means like resonates with like, and the text says such a relation is favorable. Fortune still depends on seasonal strength, the mutual hexagram, and the changed hexagram, so one table cannot settle a reading. [1]

A fuller reading also examines the mutual hexagram (lines 2–3–4 as the inner mutual, 3–4–5 as the outer) and the changed hexagram produced by the moving line. The text treats the mutual hexagram as the middle response and the changed hexagram as the final response, describing the middle process and later development.

What Questions Can It Read?

The transmitted text lists categories such as weather, people, household, marriage, money, and lost objects. Modern teaching usually groups questions like this:

  • Relationships: the current interaction and possible direction.
  • Career: timing and friction in a partnership, job search, or move.
  • Money: the conditions and risks of a transaction.
  • Lost objects: possible direction and clues.
  • Travel: arrangements and likely obstacles.
  • Sudden events: how a scene is read within traditional image-number thought.

These categories show what the tradition allows you to ask; they do not prove that it predicts real outcomes. With health, legal, investment, or safety issues, a hexagram is at most a symbolic language for organizing your thoughts, not a replacement for professional advice and verifiable information.

Meihua Yishu vs. Liu Yao

Both start from the Yijing's hexagram and line system, but they take different technical routes:

ComparisonMeihua YishuLiu Yao
Core toolPre-heaven numbers, body-use, mutual and changed hexagramsNa Jia, six relatives, self-response, six spirits
CastingTime, number, sound, object, and other numeric triggersFixed procedures such as the coin method
Rule systemRelatively compact, centred on images and body-useDetailed rules including month, day, and void branches
Judgment focusBody-use generation and control plus symbolic readingUseful-god strength plus moving-line relations
Learning curveFew entry steps; depth depends on image readingMany entry rules; more consistent once systematized
Best useSudden triggers and quick castingPrepared questions and detailed analysis
HistoryTraditionally attributed to Shao Yong; compilation disputedA Na Jia system developed over later centuries

In shorthand, Meihua leans toward image reading and Liu Yao toward a rule framework. But "better image sensitivity means more accurate readings" is not verified; sensitivity affects whether an interpretation is coherent, not whether it predicts. Liu Yao's rules are more repeatable, which also does not mean its judgments have been experimentally proven. [2]

Which One Should You Learn?

  • If you like clear rules and step-by-step reasoning, Liu Yao's useful-god and self-response system is easier to study in order.
  • If you are sensitive to trigram imagery, scenes, and language, Meihua's image reading may feel more natural.
  • If you often want to cast on a sudden moment, Meihua's varied number-taking is convenient.
  • If you want to break down a complex matter, Liu Yao's six relatives and self-response offer more structure.

It is not either-or. Learning one system's rules and limits before adding the other is usually sturdier than memorizing two sets of terms at once. Whichever you choose, keep the boundary: this is a traditional symbolic system, not a fact-prediction machine.

Try a Liu Yao readingExplore the 64 hexagrams

Sources

These sources support the studies and concepts cited in the text. Symbolic interpretations and personal exercises are the author’s views.

  1. 維基文庫 — 《梅花易數》:年月日時起卦、體用與互變規則
  2. 維基文庫 — 《增刪卜易》:納甲歌、起六神訣、安世應要領等規則

Author and content creation

Written by
Source organization
AI and Punkcan
Translation
AI
Review
Human review completed
Author profile and editorial process