Liu Yao vs. Yijing, Bagua, Bazi, and Meihua Yishu: What Is the Difference?

Liu Yao, the Yijing, Bagua, Bazi, and Meihua Yishu are often discussed together, but they belong to different layers of Chinese divination. The Yijing is a classic, Bagua are the basic trigram symbols, Liu Yao and Meihua Yishu are methods of divination, and Bazi builds a chart from birth time. Those distinctions tell you both what to study and which tool fits a question.

One thing to state up front: this article sorts out differences in structure and traditional use, not differences in predictive power. A hexagram is not a way to determine real events, career outcomes, or relationship results, and having a source link does not make a prediction valid.

Where the five terms belong

NameTypeMain materialTraditional use
YijingClassic and hexagram text64 hexagrams, judgments, line texts, and later commentariesStudying change, human affairs, and the basis of later divination
BaguaEight three-line symbolsYin and yang lines arranged as eight trigramsBuilding the 64 hexagrams
Liu YaoDivination for a specific questionOriginal and changed hexagrams, moving lines, six relatives, self and responseDiscussing the present state and later development of a matter within the tradition
Meihua YishuImage-and-number divinationTime, numbers, sounds, objects, and other triggersQuick consultations and symbolic judgment
BaziBirth-time destiny analysisThe four pillars of birth year, month, day, and hourCharacter tendencies, natal structure, and long-term timing

Start with the question. Liu Yao and Meihua Yishu sit closer to matters such as an interview result or the next stage of a negotiation. Bazi is used for a birth chart and longer periods of life. The Yijing and Bagua are where you go to study the shared language of trigrams, hexagrams, and change.

Liu Yao is both a structure and a method

The name Liu Yao has two uses. A hexagram consists of six lines arranged from bottom to top; these are its six line positions. In current practice, “studying Liu Yao” usually means learning the complete method built around those positions.

A reading may use the original hexagram, moving lines, and changed hexagram, along with Na Jia assignments, the self and response lines, six relatives, six spirits, month, day, and void. Knowing the judgments and line texts of the Yijing helps, but it does not by itself teach this technical system. Much of common Liu Yao practice was organized by later divination traditions.

The Yijing supplies the foundation; Bagua form the hexagrams

The Yijing is organized around 64 hexagrams, with a judgment for each hexagram and a text for each line. Later forms of Yijing divination developed from this material in different directions. Liu Yao is one of those paths, so the classic and the divination method should not be treated as two names for the same thing.

Bagua are the eight trigrams: Qian, Kun, Zhen, Xun, Kan, Li, Gen, and Dui. Each contains three lines. Stacking one trigram over another produces a six-line hexagram. The Xici Xia says that the eight trigrams speak through images while the line and judgment texts speak through conditions, which is exactly this division of labour: Bagua supply the basic symbols, and the line texts and judgments express situation and judgment. [1]

Bagua -> 64 hexagrams -> forms of Yijing divination
                         |-> Liu Yao
                         |-> Meihua Yishu

Liu Yao reads an event; Bazi reads a birth structure

Both systems use terms drawn from yin and yang, the five phases, stems and branches, generating and controlling relationships, clashes, and combinations. Their inputs and purposes are different. Liu Yao begins with a casting moment and a defined question. Bazi begins with the four pillars of a person's birth year, month, day, and hour.

Liu Yao is traditionally used for bounded matters: an interview, a contract, a missing object, or the near-term movement of a relationship. Bazi is commonly used for temperament, chart balance, favorable and unfavorable elements, and longer luck cycles. Using birth time to make a Liu Yao chart for an entire life, or asking Bazi for a precise answer about a temporary event, mixes their jobs.

The boundary is worth stating: even with a tightly framed question, a hexagram yields a symbolic description inside the tradition, not a determination of outcomes. Actual contracts, hiring, health, and relationships still have to be judged on real information and qualified advice.

Liu Yao and Meihua Yishu use hexagrams differently

Both belong to the broad family of Yijing-based divination. Liu Yao generally follows a defined casting and charting process, then judges moving lines, self and response, six relatives, and timing. Meihua Yishu puts more weight on images and numbers. A reading may begin from a date, a number, a sound, a written character, or an object in view, then proceed through body and function, generating and controlling relationships, and symbolic association.

Readers who prefer visible steps and explicit conditions often find Liu Yao easier to enter. Those who naturally notice environmental cues may prefer Meihua Yishu. A quick casting is not necessarily a shallow method, and a larger rule set does not make a method superior. They draw evidence and form judgments differently.

These rules are not identical across lineages. This article uses the Zeng Shan Bu Yi line as its example: the book adds Na Jia Ge, Qi Liu Shen Jue, Di Zhi Xun Cang Ge, and the eight pure trigram Na Jia diagrams at the front, together with Na Jia Yao Ling, An Shi Ying Yao Ling, a void-calculation formula, and notes on fan yin and fu yin. [2] Chart software from other lineages may assign Na Jia, self and response, and the six spirits differently, so confirm the version before comparing results.

Choose by the kind of question

  • A specific event and its near-term development: Liu Yao or Meihua Yishu.
  • Birth-chart structure and longer periods: Bazi.
  • Hexagrams, line texts, and the thought of change: the Yijing.
  • The basic symbols used to form the 64 hexagrams: Bagua.

Before asking which method is more accurate, decide whether you are examining a live event or a long-term birth chart. Then consider whether the question calls for a rule-heavy analysis or a reading led by images and numbers. A well-bounded question gives any of these methods more useful work to do.

Reference check

The basic distinctions in this article were cross-checked against the following sources:

  • Wikisource: Zhou Yi · Xi Ci Xia — the division between images and line texts, and the six lines in combination
  • Wikisource: Zeng Shan Bu Yi — Na Jia Ge, Qi Liu Shen Jue, An Shi Ying Yao Ling and related rules
  • Wikisource: Zhou Yi · Shuo Gua — the images of the eight trigrams

The account of the Yijing and Bagua follows Xi Ci Xia and Shuo Gua. The outline of Liu Yao rules uses the Zeng Shan Bu Yi line as one example rather than claiming it is the only standard version, and does not settle the differences between lineages. For Meihua Yishu, this article stays with the broad traditional category of image-and-number divination and does not make uncertain claims about textual history. These materials explain how the systems are structured; they do not support any claim that a hexagram can predict real events.

Sources

These sources support the studies and concepts cited in the text. Symbolic interpretations and personal exercises are the author’s views.

  1. 維基文庫 — 《周易 · 繫辭下》:八卦以象告,爻彖以情言
  2. 維基文庫 — 《增刪卜易》:納甲歌、起六神訣、安世應要領等規則

Author and content creation

Written by
Source organization
AI and Punkcan
Translation
AI
Review
Human review completed
Author profile and editorial process